Debate Topic #23: Should There Be a Punishment for Inappropriate Skins?

Discussion in 'Debates' started by JRaptor77, Sep 26, 2014.

?

Should there be a punishment for inappropriate skins?

  1. Yes

    22 vote(s)
    59.5%
  2. No

    15 vote(s)
    40.5%
  1. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    Discuss what you think, I've seen this come up in chat sometimes and wanted to hear your opinions ^_^

    EDIT: By inappropriate skins, I mean nude skins specifically.
     
    Last edited: Sep 26, 2014
  2. Slayer77

    Slayer77 I am Ficklinrules

    Define inappropriate skins.
     
  3. greyflick

    greyflick Jaydubb03's Assistant. Mr. GreyFlick

    Lol I don't think there should be
     
  4. Nosweg

    Nosweg The Sweg God | Quitted

    There should
    Example
    The naked skins.. mc is played by kids to
    Hitler skin..
     
    JamesM, Nyteo and JRaptor77 like this.
  5. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    Edited the first post if that helps
    Why do you think so?
     
  6. Mazari

    Mazari .

    I don't like vendetta mask related skins.
    E.G Anonymous.


    It reminds me of DDos.
     
  7. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Those people who said no are the ones who wank to naked Miley Cyrus skins.


    Just sayin'
     
  8. Sam is the MAN

    Sam is the MAN JRaptor77's godbrother

    There shouldn't be a punishment just tell them to change it, in my opinion.
    But inappropriate skins isnt very good for young people though
     
  9. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Well thats basically like someone saying "f*** off" and there being a choice between warning or punishing them

    We warn, then punish so it really should be the same with skins
     
    EA_Sharks and FireAnAntMan like this.
  10. smeags

    smeags Intentionally Philosophical

    I wonder whats inside that helmet of yours Yum... ;)

    On topic, I think there should be punishments, I mean, if you haven't heard of WWII, your education is obviously spot on.. >.>
    And its not like you should be walking around parading the guy who killed 10 million Jews.
    I can't think of any more examples atm.. xS
     
    Kalan likes this.
  11. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    I once saw a username called "Steven705" or some random numbers with a naked woman skin. Pretty sure it wasnt a girl....
     
  12. smeags

    smeags Intentionally Philosophical

    You don't find many people with the username 'Steven...' being a member of the female gender nowadays.
     
  13. WillCraftHD_FTW

    WillCraftHD_FTW got banned for advertising.

    #BanzDiblyandGingur4lyfe
     
  14. PukingRainbowz

    PukingRainbowz New Member

    Idk If @CoolCourtney1 remembers, but lots and lots of months ago I hopped onto th hub and these 2 people with nked skins ran after me,I got courtney and then those 2 people chased after her.Good Times >u<
     
    MLGProGamer123 likes this.
  15. weathers11

    weathers11 Banter King

    The naked ones i can live with, but the Hitler skins etc r bad and should be Warned. If they don't log off and come back with another skin then punished
     
  16. Nosweg

    Nosweg The Sweg God | Quitted

    It doesnt matter where you can live with.
    We have kids playing this server to.
     
  17. weathers11

    weathers11 Banter King

    Yes I agree. What I meant by it was the hitler skins etc r much more worse than the naked skins
     
  18. FireAnAntMan

    FireAnAntMan New Member

    no naked skins
     
  19. Robbin

    Robbin PukingRainbowz's Cousin

    That's a great idea... There are a lot of skins that show too much
     
  20. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    I don't mind Jesus/God skins, but Osama and Hitler are bad.
     
  21. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    But jraptor what about the duck with the thing ;-;
     
  22. Jonny_503

    Jonny_503 Guest

    2014-09-23_21.02.39.png
     
    LeMishu likes this.
  23. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

  24. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    Would just like to ask the people who voted "no" what their reasoning is, because none of those four have really explained why they think so ^_^
     
  25. There shouldn't be punishments for skins, since squadcraft is a U.S server it would kinda be violating the 1st amendment (freedom if speech). Similar to the situation were people want games like call of duty removed, call of duty doesn't have to be removed because of freedom of speech.
     
    Minion2317 likes this.
  26. YES I'm sick of seeing naked Miley Cyrus skins!
     
  27. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Does america allow people to go running round naked outside and not get punished?
     
    FireAnAntMan likes this.
  28. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Yes jk that's why I'm banned from Walmart jk
     
    MINEMAN2 likes this.
  29. As long as you don't get caught ;3, and mc is a game not irl.
     
    LeMishu likes this.
  30. Reese

    Reese Failure is success in progress

    I believe there should be a rule against inappropriate skins. Here is a little chart of what skins I think shouldn't be allowed --->

    • Swastika skins ( Skins with symbols, example: Skin with Nazi symbol )

    • Nude skins ( Skins that excessively show " body parts. " )

    • Racist/profane skins ( Skins that Racist, example: KKK skins, Or Blackface skins )
     
    MINEMAN2 likes this.
  31. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    Huh I dunno what a swastika is better explain
     
  32. Reese

    Reese Failure is success in progress

    A swastika is a symbol that represents something, and it was mainly used by German Nazi's
     
  33. LeMishu

    LeMishu "Don't do today what you can do to tomorrow."

    Blackface skins? So its against the rules to be black or what?:)
     
  34. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    It was sarcasm
     
  35. Reese

    Reese Failure is success in progress

    That's not what I meant. Blackface is a play that is whenever white people would use coal and paint there face black and mock black people. They make minecraft skins of it. I in no way shape or form have anything against " black people. "
     
  36. Reese

    Reese Failure is success in progress

    Oh.
     
  37. Minion2317

    Minion2317 smeags and madi are bae

    kinda
     
  38. __spork__

    __spork__ New Member

    Yes. No offense to any adults who play MC, but minecraft is mainly for kids, a naked person is not very... kidfriendly.
     
  39. TcWxFUSIONS

    TcWxFUSIONS Mostly known as Joey

    What makes you think adults have the naked skins?
     
  40. __spork__

    __spork__ New Member

    Nothing. If a kid has a naked person skin then it would still not be kid-friendly, if a adult has a naked person skin then it would still not be kid-friendly.
     
  41. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Adults invented and keep the youtube/server community going. I'm pretty sure it's not just for kids..
     
    Minion2317 likes this.
  42. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Boom oh snap
     
  43. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    There's a lot more "no's" than I expected o_O

    Honestly though: why? There's so many cool skins out there, instead they choose to fall in love with pixels...?
     
  44. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Jraptors i voted no because I feel people should wear whatever skin they like even if there are little kids
     
  45. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    ...
     
  46. LeMishu

    LeMishu "Don't do today what you can do to tomorrow."

    I really dont think kids see their first naked persons on minecraft:) They have internet.Voted no.
     
  47. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    That argument can be applied to cussing. Of course it isn't the first time they've seen "f***" but it's still not good for them to see
     
    EA_Sharks likes this.
  48. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    I will change my skin to a box of tissues so you guys can wipe your tears. Hahahaha its the internet, if you actually get offended by a skin it might be time to alt+f4
     
  49. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    Offended is not the word that describes why people disprove of it.



    Plus, I alt + f4 on accident all the time anyways so there
     
  50. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    It's not because they're necessarily offensive. My god people are so close minded
     
    Minion2317 likes this.
  51. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

  52. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    Why else would someone get butthurt over a skin unless tgey were offended? Give me an example of a skin thats not offensive yet you would like to see gone.
     
  53. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Naked skin. Bad influence
     
  54. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    The size of @PAPAhirs ' brain ^
     
  55. LeMishu

    LeMishu "Don't do today what you can do to tomorrow."

    Lets not make bad & stupid remarks about other players.We cant consider others stupid just because we have different opinions.
     
  56. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    -LeMishu
     
  57. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    Influence? What is it influencing them to do? Walk around naked irl?
     
    LeMishu likes this.
  58. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    'Hey look mummy look what I drew'
    Is there really a good reason to keep these skins?
     
  59. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    What kind of kid is still drawing pictures and playing pc?
     
  60. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

  61. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    One out there.
     
  62. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    Can't censor the internet so learn to live with it kiddies.
     
  63. LeMishu

    LeMishu "Don't do today what you can do to tomorrow."

    This is the first server where i see people actually asking about giving a punishment for 'inappropriate skins'.If you want everything to be decent, kid-friendly then maybe internet is not very good for you.Go read a book:))
     
    Shadow and PAPAhirs like this.
  64. Shadow

    Shadow Glongle

    Nope never the whole internet, but Squadcraft is part of the internet and we should censor it.

    Give me a reason why we would want to let them on squadcraft
     
  65. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    What else would I fap to?
     
  66. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    You must be the kind of person that would swear with your friends in the presence of little kids
     
  67. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    Hahaha and the parent of the year award goes to
     
  68. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    Err.. judging by the irrelevant response I'm guessing you misread? 0_o
     
  69. MCSmelter

    MCSmelter The Maul Awakens

    No.
     
    Sloww likes this.
  70. PukingRainbowz

    PukingRainbowz New Member

    This arguments never ganna end...

    P.s. Alot of people are under the age of 13 on squad,Half the people who actually go on squad are under 18 years old.
    @PAPAhirs ,So your saying you don't mind people walking around with a naked skin?
    If you want to 'fap' to something I don't think this is the place.You saying you cannot censor the internet,You actually can it's the same way as you see hackers.You see hackers=You jail them.
    If you give a punishment to a player it wouldn't be long,you just have to wait until that player has changed their skin.
    It's not that hard so I'm saying yus,punish the inappropriate skins.

    P.s.s We do appreciate your opinion,just your argument isn't very well thought out.
     
    EA_Sharks likes this.
  71. PAPAhirs

    PAPAhirs New Member

    Paying $10 (CAD) for a naked hitler skin... Pm me.
     
  72. PukingRainbowz

    PukingRainbowz New Member

    Carry on with your arguing,It's funny (no sarcasm intended)
     
    PAPAhirs likes this.
  73. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Wait me in my bikini doesn't count as inappropriate right? I love my bikini skins and I think there funny but I don't think there bad right?.....
     
  74. greyflick

    greyflick Jaydubb03's Assistant. Mr. GreyFlick

    Lol @InsideOutMineqhjacraft has a. Bikini (Joshy666)
     
  75. CheeseQuacks

    CheeseQuacks Everyone should use the most OP kits they can!

    "No controversial skins"
     
  76. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Yeah but he's a banana I'm taking about the inappropriate skins like the people skins that show things
     
  77. jaydubb03

    jaydubb03 [GodofS3xiness]-Squadcraft Rebel Join us!

    Ah
     
  78. greyflick

    greyflick Jaydubb03's Assistant. Mr. GreyFlick

    Mk
     
  79. DerpPlayzMC

    DerpPlayzMC I shall return shortly, as a new derp

    Well no because it's their choice what skin they have. Everyone else who has a normal skin doesn't get punished, but people that do would. So therefor this wouldn't be fair. And squadcraft would lose players because as soon as they get banned/jailed they'd go straight to another server, and sometimes when this happens they never come back.
    Sorry, but it's a No for me.
     
    Last edited: Nov 24, 2014
    Robbin likes this.
  80. Yum44

    Yum44 Zlol13's brother

    So by your logic, people should be able to relentlessly swear. They're just words right?
     
  81. Caleb Morrison

    Caleb Morrison F3arxB3astly the Sweg Master

    i want a naked skin
     
  82. JRaptor77

    JRaptor77 Cya cx

    Why are you apologizing =P

    Wanna know why people with normal skins don't get punished? It's in the statement--they're normal, not inappropriate. It is not morally right and it sure as heck is disrespecting many other people who: A) Should not be seeing that in their favorite game B) Think it is morally wrong (which it is haha). Punishing inappropriate skins wouldn't affect player count in the slightest. If you think they would leave that quickly just because their skin is against the rules, just think about how many times you got jailed/punished and came back again...Plus, how badly do we want people to stay on the server if they break rules?

    As for "you can't censor the internet", that is one of the most ignorant things I've read in a long time .-. You most certainly can "censor" things on your own server/site. It's called by setting rules, and people who break rules get punished, making it a friendlier environment for everybody


    [sorry if that sounded grumpy lol ;-;]
     
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2014
    Shadow and Yum44 like this.

Share This Page